Rank: Advanced Member
Groups: Registered
Joined: 05/03/2009(UTC) Posts: 3,255 Location: Glasgow
Thanks: 34 times Was thanked: 107 time(s) in 82 post(s)
|
Gildermershina wrote:Well, since the Sopranos and The West Wing, America has had about a million excellently written, acted and produced drama shows. Just off the top of my head, I've personally enjoyed The Sopranos, Deadwood, The Wire, Battlestar Galactica, Lost, House, Fringe, Monk, Heroes, and there's a whole bunch I'm yet to get around to. And that's not to mention comedy shows like Arrested Development, The Office (it being entirely different to the UK version), Curb Your Enthusiasm, Scrubs, Flight of the Conchords, South Park, Futurama, King of the Hill, etc.
The UK doesn't have the budget for the high-end drama, plus we only really do 6-8 episode runs compared to 22 or 24 in the US. Generally US shows have a writing staff, while here in the UK, it's usually just one or two guys. There's upsides and downsides to both, the big downside is that if you take the premier US sci-fi show at the moment, Lost, and compare it production-wise to the premier UK sci-fi show at the moment, Doctor Who, there's just no real comparison. Nobody's going to spend that much money on an adult-oriented drama series in this country because there's not a large enough audience. They spend the money on family shows like Doctor Who. Our drama series' are inevitably period costume adaptations or low budget police detective shows. I tend to think that we do low budget shows far better than the Americas though. But that's primarily because in the US if your show is low budget then you've been turned down by 18,000 channels already, where as here it's pretty much low budget or nothing. I'm also split on the 6 episode series against the longer US run. I like it from the perspective of watching stuff, especially on DVD. But on the flipside if you have a 6 episode show it's not likely to have any one episode significantly weaker than the rest. In a US season you are likely to have at least one or two episodes which just seem filler. I guess I prefer the HBO length, your 12-13 episode series. It's a good compromise. I do think we can do low budget gritty drama shows rather well. Alot of them do end up being cop shows like Taggart, Cracker, Rebus or Life On Mars, but hey, they are still really good pieces of TV. And there is The Thick Of It which I think stands up as one of the finest British television shows of the last 5-10 years. The problem is that British television is really at a spectacular low point right now. In the past we had fantastic pieces of really good serious drama, 'Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy' & 'Smiley's People', 'Edge Of Darkness', 'The Singing Detective', 'A Very British Coup' & 'Threads' all coming to mind as critically acclaimed examples from the 80s. These days our television is dominated by populist swill that cares more about ratings than anything else which is frustrating because the BBC should be above that sort of nonsense. The BBC is paid for by license payers and so while still having some elements of light entertainment in the schedule to appeal to large segments of society, it should not be the case where serious drama is either dressed up in a 19th century costume or otherwise ignored in favour of soap operas, reality shows, decorating shows and other shows which are intellectually bereft. Why does ITV exist if not for that sort of thing? I'd even happily sacrifice sport from BBC TV if we got more in the way of serious new drama shows. |