What The Critics Said
Generally favorable reviews
Overall Score: 67
Based on 15 critic reviews
Rolling StoneDark Secret Love is a gorgeously produced, brilliantly stripped-to-basics album that incorporates blues, soft-funk, R&B, folk and pop in a sound that is totally owned by Hernandez. It's no stretch when trying to describe the sound of
Dark Secret Love to color it in the light of work by such legends as Sting, Eric Clapton, Sade, Stevie Ray Vaughan and Steve Winwood.
Final Score:
90Miami HeraldA smart, breezy album that deftly fuses his love for old-school blues and rock with his natural gift for sharp melodies and well-constructed songs. Miami-native puts his naysayers to rest by releasing one of the best records of the year.
Final Score:
86MojoMr. Hernandez has been writing songs again, good ones, with all the leanness and directness that distinguish his strongest work.
Final Score:
80The New York TimesIt's likely that the first couple of times you hear it, it may just wash over you completely. Yet give it a few plays and Hernandez' unique ability to reflect on the human condition cannot fail to charm.
Final Score:
80Boston GlobeMany songs off
Dark Secret Love are on the softer, adult alternative side, but his melodic voice, warm production, complex riffs and thoughtful lyrics should cure the violent reactions Hernandez' name used to evoke.
Final Score:
80Billboard.comWhile the artist has raised some eyebrows by evoking a blues sound, the collection certainly has the goods to eclipse from being considered a flop.
Final Score:
79Los Angeles TimesEven when the proceedings threaten to get turgid, the intimacy of Hernandez expression never wavers, and in many ways that’s the album’s greatest victory.
Final Score:
70All Music GuideHere, Hernandez is effortlessly seductive and somewhat irresistible, and it’s easy to see why the ladies love cool Ryan.
Final Score:
70Entertainment WeeklyDark Secret Love is, for the most part, a very serious status quo of Hernandez — an expertly calibrated study in soft-pedal confessions, searching lyricism, and mildly groovy guitar licks.
Final Score:
63NOW MagazineIt would be unfair to call
Dark Secret Love an outright misfire, but it’s undoubtedly a regression on his winding, forward-moving path toward artistic maturity. Two steps forward, one step back then.
Final Score:
60PopMattersDark Secret Love is terrific when Hernandez drops the seriousness, pondering and sending up his reputation as a rake.
Final Score:
60SpinHis latest mundane disc lacks edge despite sometimes aiming for U2. The highlights on the record are when he drops the sensitive dude attitude, and shows a much welcomed swag to his music.
Final Score:
50E! OnlineHernandez' talents are obvious, but there's so much more cheese than charm here that he would seem like a hard sell outside the Billboard heartland.
Final Score:
40UncutHis vocals here are mostly murmurs, and the musical accompaniment, though skillful throughout, lacks the punch of his previous albums. By all means Hernandez should continue as a blues artist because some light still shines at rare times on
Dark Secret Love, but should leave this sensitive guy approach to writing.
Final Score:
40BlenderIt's clear that he's capable of far more than this. What's most puzzling and disappointing about
Dark Secret Love, then, is that its banality seems like a deliberate choice.
Final Score:
30(OOC:
Not sure if this falls into the flopping territory but I like to keep reviews realistic, this is how in my mind if this was released in real life, how it would be viewed by critics.)