OOC: I really enjoyed reading all of the stuff about the album. THanks for requesting that this be reviewed. It was a pleasure.
La Linotte - Very IndieAfter Katie Coyle made folky pop rock into a very trendy mainstream thing it seems like everyone has some kind of folk influence in their songs. Maybe it was always that way, and I am just getting to notice it more. It seems like everyone wants to catch that very indie sounding but with mainstream appeal that Coyle's album had, and usually it comes off as trying too hard. Madeline Rameau's album "La Linotte" is by no means an imitation of Katie Coyle despite being very folky. It instead takes things the opposite direction. La Linotte is very indie. The album is full of quirky jazz, folk, vocal layerings, symphonic synths, and a whole lot of French.
The album's opener, "At Home", is a slow jazzy tune with hooky piano and guitar melodies. It is an emotional opener about Rameau's hometown, growing up, and wishing to go back to childhood simplicity. The instruments set the tone for the album which follows this opening trakc with the faster "Rabbit's Feet". The song is still centered around Rameau's voice and the acoustic guitar but overdriven electric guitars give the song some variation. In this bitter breakup song Rameau declares "And I’ll always think of you,/Whether you want me too,/And I say that I’ll be the one,/Who never knew the better...". The first couple of songs aren't bad by any means, but there is a sense that Rameua is holding something back.
In track the, "Paris", the french roots really come out. The accordian, plus Rameau singing in french make this song very traditional french. The bass and guitar keep things interesting, and the melody is certainly nice. Lyrically this song could be the most cliche throw your stereo out of a hotel window type of lyrics, but they're all in French so I would never know. Next is the catchy anthemic "Rule the Night" which is partly in french, but Rameau also bitterly sings the lines "Now you’ve cut me open to drink my blood./And kick my shins so I fall in mud." which makes me wonder whether I'm listening to a jazzy folk indie act or angry punk rockers. It works out relatively well though in this song which has more of a rock n roll vibe than any of the other songs on the album. It is also produced by Jason Smith, and is one of the highlights of the album.
Next is "Le Plus Angoissantes de Bonheur" which will bring you back to the days of sitting in your friends basement and dropping a bunch of acid. It starts with random jibberish which will either be interpreted as a fantastic piece of art or jibbereish which I find to be more accurate. Loud, relatively fast, and just odd overall, the fifth addition to "La Linotte" will either leave you with a blank confused look on your face or it will be the greatest thing you've ever heard which brings us back to the acid tripping.
At this point I was sort of scratching my head, and I'm guessing unless you are a folky indie jazz junky you probably are too. The album's title track is a gamechanger. It is a beautiful epic in which Rameau declares "The things we swore would be lies have now come true.../I want to spend my life with you.". The song, which is almost eight minutes long, works perfectly. The song is the highlight of the album, and it's melodies need to go down on everyone's list of the most melodic songs of the year.
Next is the very traditional "Biting Through". The clapping, chanting, and slightly chaotic sounds make this song very metaphoric for rebellion which is seen in the reference to Robespierre. The chaos and rebellion is followed by the peaceful synthfilled folk pop of "Kissed by the Wind". Rameua happily reveals "And I don’t know what to say, ‘cept you put me in a good mood." in what is one of the simpler songs on the entire album.
"Elle a Dit" is a fun more up beat and contemporary sounding song with synth, slide guitar, and of course Rameau's great vocal performance. The more diverse instrumentals of this song make it a breath of fresh air for those who were getting tired of the very folky jazz. The rythms and vocal layering make this song a very good one. Next is the very emotional "Sing Sing Sing" in which Rameau desperately declares "The final words have been spoken.../Our story falls apart,/Of that mother with a stone.../In place of a heart," in what is lyrically probably the best song on the album. If "La Linotte" is the best song then this is the second best. The bass, violin, pian, they all work perfectly in this dark melodic masterpiece. The album then closes with "At Home (Continued)" which is a nice touch to create a full circle effect.
Overall "La Linotte" is by no means bad, but it probably wont leave you in shock and awe. It is great if folky jazz is your thing. The melodies are fantastic. Whether it will transcend out of the folk world is tough to say. It probably will just because everything Jason Smith touches finds a way to turn to gold. Whenever I start to think the album will completely blow mt mind there is a song that is just ok. Some songs come off as just too odd. Overall a decent album worthy of some attention, and some of the songs are absolutely amazing, but as an album it is just a bit too gloomy or quirky at some times to be as fantastic as some of it's songs are.
- Max Pruitt, Label Runner, and Music Reviewr Extraordinaire