Aj wrote:The majority of Western Laws and morals are basically built by the Roman Catholics are they not? I mean ten commandments and all that stuff. Now, obviously people should realise that being a good person is good because your being good rather than for fear of going to hell, but still, point remains that history does teach us that the Roman Catholic Church is very important, so how on earth is it bad? Well not now, but it did have it's uses in history. Apologies if that isn't what you mean though :P
I'm probably wrong though.
All of the Ten Commandments, being written by men, obviously already existed. Look to the great city of Babylon and you'll find an advanced civilised culture that existed before any publication of these ten commandments.
One thing that I find interesting is how revered the Commandments are, and yet how few people can actually recite them. The American public almost unanimously want the ten commandments displayed in courthouses, and yet can't name more than two or three.
While I'm all for the ones about murder, theft and adultery, the four or five (depending on your version) all about bowing down to God are just ridiculous, and then there's a pair at the end about jealousy... How is jealousy a) a crime, b) punishable. Jealousy is a natural reaction, and while I'm all for discouraging people from acting on such an emotion, calling thought a crime is just utter nonsense. Might as well just have a commandment that says "and in addition to all the previous crimes, you should also never even think about any of these acts, because that too is a crime." As for honouring mother and father, well hey sure, especially if they beat you and rape you.
The good commandments are self-evident in any society, and come through philosophy. As Aristotle once apparently said "I have gained this by philosophy - that I do without being commanded what others do only from fear of the law."
Whether that law be the law of the kingdom, or the law of god, far better for a person to do something because they believe it to be right, than to be told that it is right by way of the threat of punishment.